Skip to content
DoYourPDF

Signatures · Business

Electronic signature vs digital signature (DSC, Aadhaar eSign): which one does your form need?

A picture of your signature, Aadhaar eSign and a DSC are three different things. What each one is, what India's IT Act says, and which one a form needs.

HarshFounder, DoYourPDF8 min read

A picture of your signature on a PDF, Aadhaar eSign and a digital signature certificate (DSC) are three different things. A picture is fine for many everyday documents; a form or portal that asks for eSign or a DSC needs exactly that, and a pasted signature image won't count. Before you sign, check which one the person or office receiving it asks for.

I built Sign PDF, which does the first kind, and I get asked often whether it is "legally valid". The honest answer is that it depends on what the document needs, so here is what each kind is, what India's law says about it, and how to tell which one you need. This is a plain explainer, not legal advice.

The three kinds at a glance

Picture of your signature Aadhaar eSign Digital signature certificate (DSC)
What it is An image of your handwritten signature placed on the page An online, certificate-based signature after Aadhaar e-KYC A certificate issued to you by a licensed Certifying Authority
How you sign Draw, type or photograph it and place it Confirm with an OTP or a fingerprint or iris scan each time Use the certificate you hold (often on a USB token)
Listed in the IT Act? No Yes, in the Second Schedule Yes, section 3
Shows if the file changed later? No Yes (it is a digital signature underneath) Yes
Typical use Offer letters, rental agreements, school and bank consent forms Documents a service provider asks you to eSign online Company and LLP filings on MCA21, income tax e-verification (one option)

What the IT Act says

India's Information Technology Act, 2000, as amended in 2008, uses "electronic signature" as the wider term. It defines an electronic signature as authentication of an electronic record "by means of the electronic technique specified in the Second Schedule and includes digital signature", and section 3A lets the signer (the Act says "subscriber") authenticate a record with such a technique (IT (Amendment) Act, 2008). The 2008 amendment also changed section 5, which gives signatures legal recognition, to say "electronic signature" where it used to say "digital signature".

A digital signature is the older, narrower kind. Section 3 of the Act (unchanged in 2008) says it works by "asymmetric crypto system and hash function": a private key only you hold, a public key anyone can check it with, and a fingerprint of the document that shows if anything changed after signing (IT Act, 2000, CCA). A DSC is the certificate that ties such a key to you.

Aadhaar eSign came in January 2015, when the government notified an "e-authentication technique using Aadhaar e-KYC Services" (G.S.R. 61(E)); a 2019 amendment to the Second Schedule extended it to other e-KYC services along with Aadhaar (Controller of Certifying Authorities, gazette notifications).

A picture of a handwritten signature placed on a PDF is neither of these. That doesn't make it worthless: people sign rental agreements and offer letters this way every day. It means the Act's rules for electronic signatures don't cover it, and a portal or law that asks for an electronic signature in the Act's sense won't accept it.

Documents the Act doesn't cover

The First Schedule lists documents the Act does not apply to at all (IT (Amendment) Act, 2008). A 2022 notification, S.O. 4720(E), changed the list (CCA). Today it covers:

  • Negotiable instruments other than cheques. Since 2022, a demand promissory note or bill of exchange issued in favour of, or endorsed by, an entity regulated by RBI, NHB, SEBI, IRDAI or PFRDA is also outside this exclusion.
  • Powers of attorney, except those that empower such a regulated entity to act for the person signing them.
  • Trusts.
  • Wills.

Contracts for the sale or conveyance of immovable property were on the list until 2022, when the notification removed them. That doesn't make a property sale a click-to-sign job: stamp duty and registration laws still set their own requirements. For anything excluded, no kind of electronic signature replaces the formalities the law already sets.

Aadhaar eSign, in plain words

The Controller of Certifying Authorities (CCA) describes eSign as "an online service for electronic signatures without using physical hardware tokens" (CCA eSign brochure). From that brochure:

  • You don't buy anything. The service you're signing with (an app, a portal, a bank) sends you to an eSign Service Provider, which, the brochure says, is currently one of the Certifying Authorities licensed under the IT Act.
  • You confirm who you are through Aadhaar e-KYC, with an OTP or a fingerprint or iris scan.
  • Your document isn't sent whole. Only its hash, a short fingerprint of the file, goes for signing.
  • The key is used once. It is created in a hardware security module and destroyed right after that one signature.
  • It is a digital signature underneath. The brochure's steps include a Digital Signature Certificate request and creating a digital signature on the document's hash, so, like a DSC signature, it shows if the file is changed afterwards.

The brochure lists uses such as DigiLocker, tax filing, opening a bank account, driving licence renewal, passport applications, and course enrolment and exams. In practice, you meet eSign as a step in a service that offers it.

DSC, in plain words

A DSC is issued to you by a Certifying Authority licensed by the CCA, and you keep using it until it expires. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs says all filings by companies and LLPs under MCA21 "are required to be filed using Digital Signatures", and that DSCs are typically issued for one or two years and can be renewed (MCA). That page is from MCA's older V2 site, so check the current MCA21 portal for the class of certificate it accepts today.

For income tax, a DSC is one option, not a requirement for everyone. The e-filing help lists e-verifying a return with a Digital Signature Certificate, Aadhaar OTP, an electronic verification code through a bank or demat account or a bank ATM, or net banking, and for the DSC route it expects a USB token. It cites a notification setting 30 days from filing for e-verification or sending ITR-V (Income Tax Department).

Which one does your document need?

Go by what the receiver asks for, in this order:

  1. The portal or form names it. If it says DSC, eSign or "digitally signed", that is what it needs. A picture won't pass the check.
  2. It's a government filing. Look at that portal's own help for the verification options. Income tax gives you several; company filings on MCA21 need a DSC.
  3. Someone emailed you a document to sign and send back. An offer letter, a rental agreement, a declaration, a school or college form: most of these ask only for your signature on the page. A picture placed with Sign PDF, or a printout signed with a pen and scanned, is usually what they expect. If you're not sure, ask them before you send it.
  4. It's a will, a power of attorney or a property document. The IT Act doesn't apply to wills or most powers of attorney, and property deals have their own stamp duty and registration rules; follow the formalities for that document, and take advice if you need it.

Signing with a picture, done well

When a picture of your signature is what's needed:

  • Fill in any boxes first with Fill PDF Form, then sign the filled copy.
  • Open Sign PDF, draw, type or photograph your signature, place it, add the date if the form asks, and save. The signed copy downloads with -signed at the end of its name. Step by step: how to sign a PDF on your phone.
  • If the office wants a pen signature, sign a printout and turn it back into a PDF with Scan to PDF.
Sign PDFPlace a signature on any page, at any size. Free, works on your device, nothing uploaded

Everything happens in your browser; the PDF and your signature are never uploaded.

If the PDF is already digitally signed

Some PDFs arrive with a digital signature from whoever issued them, like e-Aadhaar, an e-PAN or a CAS from NSDL. Changing such a file in any way, with any editor, means that signature no longer checks out. Sign PDF and the other tools here save a new copy, so the issuer's signature doesn't carry over to it. Keep the original download and send that whenever someone needs to verify it; see the guides to masked Aadhaar, e-PAN and CAS passwords.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between an electronic signature and a digital signature in India?

In the Information Technology Act, "electronic signature" is the wider term. A digital signature, made with a certificate and a private key (a DSC), is one kind of electronic signature; Aadhaar eSign is another, notified in 2015 and listed in the Act's Second Schedule. A picture of your handwritten signature placed on a PDF is not one of the techniques the Act lists.

Is Aadhaar eSign the same as a DSC?

Both rely on certificates from Certifying Authorities licensed under the IT Act (the CCA says eSign providers are currently licensed Certifying Authorities), but you use them differently. With eSign you confirm your identity through Aadhaar e-KYC (an OTP or a fingerprint or iris scan) each time you sign, and the signing key is created for that one use and then destroyed. A DSC is a certificate issued to you that you keep and use again; for income tax e-verification it sits on a USB token.

Is a signature added with Sign PDF legally valid?

Sign PDF places a picture of your signature on the page, like signing a printout. Many people and organisations accept that for everyday documents such as offer letters and consent forms. It is not a DSC or Aadhaar eSign, so it will not do where a portal or law asks for one. Whether it is enough for a particular document is up to whoever receives it; for anything with legal weight, ask them or a lawyer.

Which documents does the IT Act not apply to?

The IT Act's First Schedule, as amended in 2022, lists negotiable instruments other than cheques (with exceptions for some promissory notes and bills of exchange in favour of entities regulated by RBI, NHB, SEBI, IRDAI or PFRDA), powers of attorney (except some that empower such regulated entities), trusts, and wills. Contracts for the sale of immovable property were removed from the list in 2022, but stamp duty and registration laws still apply to them.

Do I need a DSC to file my income tax return?

Not necessarily. The Income Tax Department's e-filing help lists several ways to e-verify a return, including Aadhaar OTP, an electronic verification code through a bank or demat account, net banking, and a digital signature certificate. Notification No. 5/2022, effective 1 August 2022, sets 30 days from filing for e-verification or sending ITR-V.

Tools in this guide

Fill PDF FormFill in form fields, then save or flatten. Free, works on your device, nothing uploadedScan to PDFUse your camera: crop, straighten, clean up, save. Free, works on your device, nothing uploaded

More guides